With that being said, I noticed in chapter two Li and Bernoff write about making profiles for a social media site. Within these profiles one makes relationships with others. Li and Bernoff then write a short paragraph about going beyond simple profiles and dipping into the realm of virtual worlds. I wished they discussed this more because I think it is an interesting topic. Bernoff and Li write,
"Participants here can express themselves by how they look and what they wear; a fifty-year-old fat and balding technical worker can be a muscular stud in a black turtleneck or a buxom Barbie if he wants. While social networks have exploded, virtual worlds have not yet expanded into the broader online world" (Li and Bernoff 22).
Although this was some harsh wording (fat and bald) from Li and Bernoff, I think this small paragrpah says a lot about our culture and social media.
First, when making a social media profile, I think people are already fitting the "virtual world" part, in the sense that people really care about their profile image. Every social media app allows you to upload a picture to show to others who you are, and I think most people care about that image and what it portrays/symbolizes. I am not saying everyone necessarily recreates themselves, but I do think people portray themselves in a way they might not in real life. Confidence, charisma, and even physical traits such as weight are all factors that can be tweaked or managed on a social media site. This is different than virtual worlds such as Second Life, but I wanted to make the point that there is some interchange and connection between the two.
Second, I wonder why virtual worlds have not expanded? Why have they not reached the level of social media? Is it the fear that people will lose their own self and identity? Will stereotypes change or become even more enforced? When I read this Groundswell paragraph I instantly thought of a 2009 film that was actually shot in Worcester called Surrogates. The synopsis is pretty much the same exact thing as Li and Bernoff describe: balding fat men staying home all day while actually living their day to day lives through a machine as their ideal prototype.
Here is the trailer:
Social media is so new and because of this it is also open for interpretation and critique. I spent an entire blog post on a subject Li and Bernoff spent 30 words on.
But, I really do feel like researches of social media need to spend more time on what social media is doing to our self identity and interpersonal interaction with each other. Is it a good thing or a bad thing? That all depends if you are an optimist or a pessimist. I am still a little undecided.
Well, from my view, I think social media shorten the actual distant between each other. For example, I may know the latest news about my junior school classmates via Facebook. If I join a junior school reunion, we will have a lot of common topic to chat. No matter where I am, no matter how many years we didn't meet, we still close to each other. But, I think your worried is justified. Sometimes people don't chat, because they addict to social networking or others. It's really hard to say.
ReplyDeleteThe internet has definitely provide people with a stage to be who they want to be since not everything needs to be verified (other than the email you set up your account with maybe). Recently a friend of mine committed suicide. He had such a optimistic, cheering, shining social media profile that we all thought he was doing great after graduation, but apparently it wasn't the reality. That really made me think about people's appearances on social media. Is it a good thing that we could live another life online and hide our true self if we want to, or is it taking us apart from some real connection and intercommunication?
ReplyDeleteI think you make a very good point in this post. People definitely use social media to portray themselves in a certain way. We "untag" pictures we don't like of ourselves to filter out some of our insecurities. The two video examples that you gave were really good ones, but I also thought of the show Catfish on MTV. Although that is about online dating, it still presents the same type of situation. People often pretend to be something they are not, or play down features that they may not be proud of.
ReplyDeleteWe used to say that the internet and social opportunities make us closer to each other and let us show the real face, it blurs the boundaries and distance us at the same time. People are afraid to show their appearance and real emotions they prefer to hide it deep inside but that's more the question of psychology and lack of self-confidence. People are cruel, social media just gives opportunity to hide and make the problem bigger instead of illuminating it.
ReplyDelete