Wednesday, October 2, 2013

Rebecca Black, Lack of Creativity, and Participatory Culture

Hello Folks! I have to admit, I might sound a little indecisive in this post. This is something I have been thinking about for awhile, so it will be nice to write it out and express my thoughts. My first original post dealt with Lil B and his strategic use of social media for his successful production of music. Now, I am writing about Rebecca Black, another musician who used social media for success. Rebecca Black's story is different than Lil B's though.
Rebecca Black gained instant internet fame in 2011 with her song and video "Friday" through ARK Music Factory. It works like this: you pay ARK $4,000 and they make you a song and video. All you have to do is sing it and they take care of the rest (that includes vocal effects). Black did this with "Friday" and before long her video hit millions of views.
"Friday" was ripped open by music critics. Lindsay Parker of Yahoo Music questioned if it was the worst song ever? Others call it bizarre while some just call it dreadful.

My issue with Rebecca Black and “Friday” is that she (her parents) more or less paid for his musical success. Music has always been about creation and creative expression. And yes, there have been plenty of musicians who never even wrote a song, but at least they still had a good voice! I am not trying to diss or offend Rebecca Black, but I think the girl really lacks musical talent.



Now what you just read is my pessimistic point of view. On the contrary, I also think it’s great that a young girl like Rebecca Black can now fulfill one of her biggest dreams through this music production company. This is the first time in musical history that someone her age can reach such a large audience. I would just prefer that young person to be a really talented rapper or awesome guitar player.

And on top of all of this comes the participatory culture aspect of Rebecca Black’s YouTube fame. I already told you what some “professional” critics had to say about her. Professional critics can be blunt, but they are professional. They can be honest, but they can’t be offensive.

Part of participatory culture is that the people can say whatever they want, and they can say it however they want. Rebecca Black’s video has the most dislikes of any YouTube video ever! How can that make this young girl feel? You can only imagine what some of the comments say. These comments and dislikes would crush anyone, let alone a 14 year old girl.  Again, this is one of those moments where I am really conflicted about social media and music. Rebecca Black finally has the chance to fulfill her dreams, and she does so; but at what expense? She now has to face the wrath of participatory culture and the people behind it.




All in all, I would not agree with Rebecca Black’s situation. I think she is too young to have to deal with this internet fame and what comes with it, especially if most people are just poking fun at her. She is too young to understand participatory culture and what it really means for her. Too young to understand how to use it to your advantage and actually help you rather than hurt you. Whatever happened to making a video and just showing your best friends? That’s what I used to do and things turned out all right for me. But who am I to talk, she also has a net worth of over a million dollars. Maybe the joke is on me?

Verdict: NAY

Sources:

http://music.yahoo.com/blogs/stop-the-presses/is-youtube-sensation-rebecca-blacks-friday-the-worst-song-ever.html

http://music-mix.ew.com/2011/03/14/rebecca-black-friday-music-video/

http://newsfeed.time.com/2011/03/14/rebecca-blacks-bizarrely-bad-video-for-friday-is-this-for-real/

http://arkmusicfactory.com/

2 comments:

  1. I quite agree with your point of view that " She is too young to understand how to use it to her advantage and actually help her rather than hurt her". In today's social media world, you never know what happens next if you post your personal photo or video on the Internet just for fun! There are a lot of factors we should consider. So, how to use social medias rationally and appropriately is an important question for all of us.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I completely agree with you. However, I feel like her situation is not common. I'm guessing that that recording company makes a lot of these music videos and posts them on YouTube for people to watch. Black's video got more attention than most. I think on the one hand, Black is too young to be faced with this type of negative culture, but at the same time, she is still achieving a dream of some sort. As they say "any publicity is good publicity" and for Black, this video allowed her to go to red carpet events, meet celebrities, go on talk shows, and live a life many kids could only dream of.

    ReplyDelete